Both Breaths

A few weeks ago I sat in a circle of women, talking about trust and action and whether they are opposites, whether we have to choose one or the other. Somewhere in that conversation I got stuck. Words like trust, devotion, commitment... they are loaded for me, heavy with years of being told what they were supposed to look like. And when I finally noticed my body, my shoulders had crept up toward my ears and I was barely breathing. Small, shallow sips of air, high in my chest.

So I did what I so often invite my clients to do. I placed a gentle hand on my belly, let a slow breath in... and let it go.

Breath is such a quiet wonder. We breathe around twenty thousand times a day and hardly ever notice. And yet the inhale and the exhale are completely different movements in the body. When we breathe in, the diaphragm tightens and pulls down, drawing air into the lungs. When we breathe out, it softens, and the body mostly just lets go. The inhale quickens the heart a little, the exhale slows it. They move in opposite directions, and still they need each other completely. Each breath out makes room for the next breath in, and I couldn't live on only one of them even if I tried.

I often think of the places in our lives that pull in opposite directions in this same way.

In my work with women I hear it all the time. I love my family and I need distance from them. I long to be seen and I am terrified of being seen. And so often, I was taught my faith has to look a certain way, and it doesn't look that way anymore. Some women are still sitting in the pews with questions they can't say out loud. Some have walked away and are surprised to find they still ache for something sacred. Many of us were taught that doubt and faith can't live in the same body, that holding both made us double-minded or unfaithful. So we pick a side and hold our breath against the other... and we can only hold it for so long.

Trust and action have been like this for me. For a long time I thought I had to choose. Either I waited and trusted, or I pushed and did. But when I sit quietly with my breath, the inhale feels a lot like trust, opening to receive something I didn't make myself. And the exhale feels like action, offering something back out into the world. I have held my breath in trust, waiting and waiting, and I have pushed every bit of air out of me in doing. Neither one left me nourished for very long. So maybe they were never meant to be separated. Maybe they belong to the same breath.

Maybe you know the old Greek story of Persephone, who spends part of each year in the underworld and part of it above in the light. The seasons turn because she belongs to both worlds. The earth rests while she is below and blooms when she comes back up, and it needs both. In Goddesses in Everywoman, Jungian analyst Jean Shinoda Bolen writes about Persephone as a part of many women's lives, the one who has been down into the underworld and can come back to guide others through it. I love that... the woman who knows the dark becomes someone who can walk with others there.

I recently watched the filmed stage production of Hadestown, and there are so many layers to it that I could talk about it for days. It changed something in how I see the giving and receiving of love, and how systems can oppress us and keep us from both. I am still finding words for it. In this telling, the rhythm gets broken. Hades, afraid of losing her, calls Persephone back down earlier every year and keeps her longer. Spring and fall begin to disappear, and the world above swings between harsh extremes. It is only when the two of them remember how to love each other again that the seasons have a chance to return.

I can't stop thinking about that. So many of us have been held in one world for a long time, told to stay in the light and never speak of the dark, or stuck so long in the dark that we've forgotten the light is ours too. In Learning to Walk in the Dark, Barbara Brown Taylor wonders what we miss when faith only honors the light, and how much there is to learn in the dark. Maybe we don't truly know the light until we have been in the darkness. Maybe the going down and the coming back up are both part of what makes us whole.

I am noticing something else too. Shallow breath will keep us going, and most of us live there more than we realize. But the deep breath, the slow and intentional one, brings more oxygen, slows the heart, and tells the nervous system it is safe to settle. And that deeper inhale only comes after a fuller exhale. I wonder if holding our paradoxes works this way. When I rush to make the tension one thing or the other, I am breathing shallow. When I slow down and let both be there, something in me softens. There is a softness in this that I can actually enter... I am still learning all it brings, but it feels a lot like being alive.

What are you holding right now that feels like two things pulling against each other? What if each one is part of what keeps the other alive? What might it be like to let both breaths be there, gently, and see what they bring?

If you'd like, here are a few gentle ways to begin:

•      Place one hand on your chest and one on your belly, and notice where your breath is living right now.

•      Name one side of your tension as you breathe in, and the other as you breathe out. Let them take turns.

•      Let the exhale be a little longer than the inhale, and notice how much room it makes for the next breath.

Breathe in. Breathe out. Invite gentleness as you find the rhythm... you need them both, and both are bringing you something.

Next
Next

What the Mother Trees Know